Sealy vs Serta vs Logan & Cove Mattress Comparison (2024)

Sam Kulathilaka

Sleep Content Specialist

• Up-to-Date

  i

  The information included in each mattress review at the time of publication is accurate to the best of our knowledge.
  
  Our reviews do not speak for future versions of these mattresses.

• Methodology

  i

  We test and review the industry’s most popular mattresses using a weighted scoring system factoring in 40+ criteria.
  Learn more >

Which Is Better: Sealy, Serta, or Logan & Cove?

Logan & Cove, Sealy, and Serta are all well-known mattress brands available in Canada. But only Logan & Cove Choice offers advanced cooling features, a 365-night sleep trial, a 15-year warranty, and a free bedding bundle with your purchase—all at an affordable price of $999 for a queen size. Overall, Logan & Cove Choice offers the best value for the lowest price.

Best Hybrid

Winner:

Logan & Cove

Logan & Cove Choice outscored both Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione and Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall in head-to-head testing conducted by third-party engineers (commissioned by us).

BLACK FRIDAY SALE!
Receive a FREE Bedding Bundle and 50% OFF all Duvets with any mattress purchase. Plus, enjoy 20% OFF Adjustable Beds and up to 70% OFF all bedding!
Sale ends November 29th. See website for details >

Read Review Shop Now

What We Love

• Accessibly priced at just $999 for a queen size
• 365-night sleep trial to make sure you love your mattress
• Free bedding bundle with mattress/pillow protector(s), sheets, and pillow(s)

Overall Ratings

Edge support and motion isolation are factored into our overall mattress ratings. These scores are shown in green (scores of 5.0+), yellow (3.0–4.9), or red (2.9 and below). Firmness, bounce, and cooling features are a matter of personal preference and aren’t part of our rating system, so these scores are shown in grey.

?

Determined by how much the mattress sinks under applied weight. The lower the score out of 10, the softer the mattress.

6.9 /10

Firmness

?

Determined by how much the mattress edge sinks under applied weight. A mattress with average to good edge support will score 5/10 or higher.

7.5 /10

Edge Support

?

Determined by measuring a medicine ball’s impact on the mattress. Average to good motion isolation would be 5/10 or higher.

7.5 /10

Motion Isolation

?

Determined by dropping a medicine ball onto the mattress. The higher the first bounce, the higher the score out of 10.

5.8 /10

Bounce

?

Determined by entering a mattress’s cooling features into our scoring algorithm. The more effective cooling features that are present, the higher the score out of 10.

4.4 /10

Cooling Features

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Breakdown

When comparing Logan & Cove vs Sealy vs Serta, Logan & Cove Choice stands out in many categories.

Logan & Cove offers a generous 365-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty. It comes with luxury details not often found outside of a mattress showroom, with advanced cooling features to keep you comfortable while you sleep. For added value, Logan & Cove mattresses also come with a free bedding bundle that includes a mattress protector, pillow(s), sheets, and pillow protector(s).

In comparison, mattresses that are sold at Sleep Country—like Sealy and Serta—don’t come with a true sleep trial. You can try a Sealy or Serta mattress at home for 100 nights, but if it doesn’t work for you, you can only exchange it for a different mattress. Sleep Country doesn’t give refunds.

Serta and Sealy come with only an industry-standard 10-year warranty, and you won’t receive a free bedding bundle with your purchase. It’s also worth noting that Sleep Country mattresses are regularly discontinued, making it harder to find a mattress that’s right for you.

To help you choose between Logan & Cove, Sealy, and Serta, we’ve gathered all the information you need to accurately compare these mattresses.

Logan & Cove Choice 9.6 BLACK FRIDAY SALE! Receive a FREE Bedding Bundle and 50% OFF all Duvets with any mattress purchase. Plus, enjoy 20% OFF Adjustable Beds and up to 70% OFF all bedding! Sale ends November 29th. See website for details >

Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione 3.1

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall 4.0

Read Logan & Cove Review	Read Sealy Review	Read Serta Review
Price (Queen)
$999	$2,399	$1,389
Sleep Trial Nights
365	100	100
Warranty Years
15	10	10
Feel
Medium-firm	Medium-firm	Firm
Standout Features
365-night sleep trial 15-year warranty Ideal for side, back, and stomach sleepers Superior motion isolation and above-average edge support Advanced cooling features Available in a full range of standard sizes Free pickups and returns in metro areas Free bedding bundle with mattress protector, pillow(s), sheets, and pillow protector(s) “A+” BBB rating and “Excellent” Trustpilot rating	100-night sleep trial 10-year warranty Suitable for side, back, and stomach sleepers Excellent edge support and above-average motion isolation Some cooling features	100-night sleep trial 10-year warranty Suitable for back and stomach sleepers Excellent edge support and above-average motion isolation Antimicrobial mattress cover
Made In
Canada	Canada	Canada

Get the mattress with a longer sleep trial and warranty for a lower price.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Sizes & Prices

^{* Based on standard sizing. Individual mattress dimensions may vary.}

Get a mattress for your budget in the perfect size when you shop Logan & Cove.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Performance Results

Firmness

According to third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us), Logan & Cove Choice has a firmness score of 6.9/10, placing it on the firmer side of the medium-firm category. Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione scored 6.2/10, which also falls into the medium-firm category.

Medium-firm mattresses are ideal for all sleep styles because they provide a good balance of comfort and support. You should find either mattress provides a comfortable level of firmness, whether you sleep on your side, back, or stomach.

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall, on the other hand, scored 7.6/10 for firmness. This places the mattress in the firm category. While back and stomach sleepers might find Percevall offers good support, it’s not ideal for side sleepers. You might notice added pressure on your shoulder and hip.

Edge Support

Hybrid mattresses generally have better edge support than foam mattresses, thanks to their metal inner coils. Logan & Cove Choice has very good edge support, with a score of 7.5/10. Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione also received an above-average score for edge support at 8.5/10, while Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall scored 9.5/10.

All three of these mattresses will let you comfortably sit or lie on the bed’s edge without any fear of slipping off. You should also be able to get out of bed without any trouble.

Motion Isolation

Good motion isolation lets you sleep on a mattress peacefully without being disturbed by your partner, kids, or pets. Movements on one side of the bed are barely noticeable on the other, ensuring uninterrupted rest for everyone.

If you’re searching for a mattress with excellent motion isolation, Logan & Cove Choice outperforms the rest with a score of 7.5/10 in third-party engineer testing.

Sealy scored 7.1/10, while Serta scored 6.3/10. Both mattresses offer good motion isolation. You should be able to sleep interruption-free on all three mattresses. However, if you are a light sleeper—or if you share your bed with others—you may notice the most restful sleep with Logan & Cove Choice.

Bounce

Innerspring and hybrid mattresses tend to be bouncier and “springier” than all-foam ones. While bounce is more of a preference, it can indicate how easily you can change sleep positions and whether you might feel “stuck” in the mattress. A higher bounce score can make it easier to get out of bed and change positions.

Comparing Serta vs Sealy, Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione scored 2.9/10 for bounce. This is quite low, even for a foam mattress. In comparison, Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall earned a bounce score of 7.8/10, which is very high, even for a hybrid mattress.

Logan & Cove Choice has a slightly above-average score of 5.8/10—a good mid-point in comparison to the other two mattresses. Coupled with this mattress’s excellent motion isolation, you will be able to experience undisturbed sleep, while also being able to easily get out of bed. 

Cooling Features

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall earned a cooling features score of 1.8/10. While the mattress is advertised as having cooling properties, there’s limited information available about the exact materials used. Percevall earned points for its cooling mattress cover, layers of temperature-regulating cooling gel foam, individually wrapped coils that allow for air circulation, and support foam with undisclosed cooling technology.

Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione performed slightly better with a score of 2.4/10, despite having fewer cooling features. This is because the brand provides a little more information about the mattress cover, which is made with cooling yarn for a cool-to-the-touch sensation when you first lie down. The mattress also comes with a layer of gel-infused memory foam that absorbs and redistributes body heat.

For cooling features, Logan & Cove Choice was the top performer with a score of 4.4/10. Choice has a cooling top cover with gel-infused foam and cooling nanofibres, as well as an additional layer of gel foam to dissipate heat, pocket coils that promote airflow, and a layer of breathable Elastex® foam. If you want a refreshing mattress to keep temperatures balanced as you sleep, Logan & Cove Choice is the best option of the three.

Get superior cooling and motion isolation with Logan & Cove.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Construction

Logan & Cove Choice and Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall are both hybrid mattresses, while Sealy Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione is a foam mattress. All three mattresses are CertiPUR-US® certified, but they have varying layers and construction to provide different benefits.

Logan & Cove Choice Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The first layer is 1″ of breathable hollow fibre fill and cooling gel-infused foam. It’s quilted directly under the tight-top cover, providing a degree of plushness and directly dissipating your body heat when you’re lying down.
• Layer 2: The second layer is 1″ of ecoLuxe® cooling gel foam. This foam layer provides excellent comfort and pressure-point relief, conforming to your body’s shape while also wicking away heat and moisture.
• Layer 3: The third layer is 1″ of Elastex® foam. This layer contours around your body, providing latex-like responsiveness and pressure relief, but without any of the allergy-causing chemicals in many natural latex mattresses.
• Layer 4: The support layer is 9″ of individually pocketed coils. Made of double-tempered steel, these coils are divided into 3 body-supporting zones to give contouring support for your back and hips. This layer is also encased with 4″-thick edge support foam along the sidewalls to give you more support when sitting on your bed, or lying farther away from the middle.

Logan & Cove Choice stands 12″ tall and contains 4 layers. The cover is made of polyester, high-density polyethylene (HDPE), and spandex. Choice offers a level of plushness and luxury detailing not often seen in the bed-in-a-box industry. The quilted tight-top, which is integrated directly into the mattress, is woven with cooling nanofibres, a breathable hollow fill, and gel-infused foam. It’s not removable or machine washable.

Sealy Posturepedic Chill Trio Dione Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The top (comfort) layer is 3″ of cooling gel memory foam. This layer shapes itself around your body as you lie down. Foam density is unknown.
• Layer 2: The bottom (support) layer is 8″ of higher-density foam, although exact foam density is unknown. In addition to acting as the mattress’s foundation, the rigidity of this layer prevents you from sinking too far into the mattress.

Sealy Posturepedic Chill Trio Dione stands 11″ tall (not 10″ as stated on the Sleep Country website). Unlike other memory foam mattresses at this price point, Chill Trio Dione only has 2 interior foam layers.

At the time we tested this mattress, Sleep Country stated that Chill Trio Dione contains “generous layers of quick response OptiSense™ Liquid Gel Memory Foam.” However, according to the infographic we received from their customer service team, only the top layer uses this foam.

The Ultra-Stretch Chill-Trio™ Cover contains cooling yarn that’s meant to absorb and dissipate heat. This cover isn’t machine washable, even though it has a zipper, so you’ll need to carefully spot-clean any spills or stains.

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The top (comfort) layer is 1″ foam that’s been quilted into pockets. Technically, this layer is actually two separate sheets of 0.5″ foam. We consider this one layer because the foam sheets are physically attached and combined to form the top layer.
• Layer 2: This layer is 2″ of relatively dense foam, preventing you from feeling the coils as they adjust to your body’s movements. However, with its denser feel, you may not experience the full contouring benefits of the coil layer below.
• Layer 3: 8″ individually pocketed coils provide full-body support. These coils aren’t used along Percevall’s sidewalls. The sidewalls are instead supported using 3″ support foam, which contributes to the mattress’s excellent edge support score.
• Layer 4: At the bottom of the mattress, 0.5″ of foam provides a little extra support below the pocketed coils.

Serta Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall is a hybrid mattress with 4 distinct layers, and it stands 11.5″ high. Serta indicates that the Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall uses Serta® Support Gel Foam. It’s not clear whether this foam is used in the first or second layer.

The mattress cover uses antimicrobial fabric woven with silver fibres to help keep the mattress cool and fresh. However, Percevall’s mattress cover is not removable or machine washable.

Get the mattress with most cooling features and a plush surface.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Delivery, Sleep Trial & Returns

When you’re comparing delivery, sleep trial, delivery, and warranty for Logan & Cove vs Sealy vs Serta, there’s a clear winner. Logan & Cove has the longest sleep trial and warranty of all three mattresses—and only Logan & Cove provides a full refund during the sleep trial period.

Logan & Cove Choice

Logan & Cove ships mattresses to most of Canada via FedEx, with free shipping for most customers nationwide. Additional fees may apply for some remote locations. Your order ships by ground from Alberta or Ontario. It’ll be on your doorstep within 2–11 business days, including dispatch and delivery time.

The mattress is delivered to your doorstep in a cardboard box and is protected by two layers of heavy-duty plastic. Once unrolled, Logan & Cove Choice expands to its full size within minutes of unpacking.

Logan & Cove’s generous 365-night sleep trial is one of Canada’s longest. If you decide to return your mattress within the trial period, the company offers free return pickup with a full refund. Returned mattresses are either donated or recycled, depending on regulations and availability in your area.

Logan & Cove also stands behind their products with a 15-year warranty, which is much longer than both Sealy and Serta’s warranty policies.

Sealy & Serta 

Note: Both Serta Sleeper Elite Percevall and Sealy Posturepedic Chill Trio Dione have been discontinued and are no longer available for purchase through Sleep Country. You may still be able to find them through some mattress resellers. We purchased both of these mattresses from Sleep Country, so the information in this section is specific to Sleep Country’s delivery, sleep trial, and return practices.

Sealy has discontinued Posturepedic Optimum Chill Trio Dione, and Serta has discontinued Perfect Sleeper Elite Percevall. In our experience, it’s common for brands like Sealy and Serta to discontinue models after less than a year. This can be frustrating for customers who have planned in advance to purchase a particular mattress, only to find that it’s been discontinued when they’re ready to buy it.

Sleep Country Canada offers free shipping for online orders over $75. Mattresses typically ship from Sleep Country within 3–10 business days (including dispatch and delivery time), depending on the company’s inventory and delivery schedule. With mattresses purchased through Sleep Country, you can choose between standard delivery service (free) or an upgrade to Green Glove Delivery ($59). This includes delivery to a specific room in your home, setup and assembly, and removal of your old mattress and any packaging.

You’ll have the opportunity to test a Sealy or Serta mattress at home during Sleep Country’s 100-night sleep trial. If you decide to return your mattress, you’ll have to bring it back to the store yourself. Sleep Country doesn’t provide pickup service for returned mattresses.

You also won’t receive a full refund for your purchase. Sleep Country only offers in-store credit for returns, and you’ll need to pay a $65 exchange fee. This means you’ll either select a less expensive mattress and have to buy other items to spend your store credit, or spend even more money to upgrade to a better mattress. There’s also no guarantee that the replacement mattress will work for your needs.

Sleep Country Canada offers a 10-year warranty on their mattresses. However, the company has received a number of customer complaints on Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot about getting warranty claims honoured.

Choose the company with the 365-night sleep trial and 15-year warranty.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Should You Buy Logan & Cove, Sealy or Serta?

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice