Logan & Cove vs Stearns & Foster Mattress Comparison (2024)

Sam Kulathilaka

Sleep Content Specialist

• Up-to-Date

  i

  The information included in each mattress review at the time of publication is accurate to the best of our knowledge.
  
  Our reviews do not speak for future versions of these mattresses.

• Methodology

  i

  We test and review the industry’s most popular mattresses using a weighted scoring system factoring in 40+ criteria.
  Learn more >

Which Is Better: Stearns & Foster or Logan & Cove?

Stearns & Foster and Logan & Cove are both hybrid mattresses with above-average motion isolation and a medium-firm feel that caters to various sleep styles. Beyond that, there is no comparison—Logan & Cove is the clear winner.

Only Logan & Cove Choice comes with a risk-free 365-night sleep trial, a 15-year warranty, and free return shipping with full refunds. At just $999 for a queen size, Logan & Cove pairs hotel-quality sleep with unmatched value. In comparison, Stearns & Foster Lakeridge is only available at Costco, comes with only a N/A-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty, and costs $1,199 for a queen size.

Best Hybrid

Winner:

Logan & Cove

Logan & Cove Choice outscored Stearns & Foster Lakeridge in head-to-head mattress testing conducted by third-party engineers (commissioned by us).

EARLY BLACK FRIDAY SALE!
Get a FREE Bedding Bundle, 50% off Down Alternative Duvets, and 15% off all bedding and bed frames with any mattress purchase.
Sale ends November 20th. See website for details >

Read Review Shop Now

What We Love

• Accessibly priced at just $999 for a queen size
• Free bedding bundle with mattress/pillow protectors, sheets, and pillow(s)
• High customer satisfaction with an “A+” BBB rating and “Excellent” Trustpilot rating

Overall Ratings

Edge support and motion isolation are factored into our overall mattress ratings. These scores are shown in green (scores of 5.0+), yellow (3.0–4.9), or red (2.9 and below). Firmness, bounce, and cooling features are a matter of personal preference and aren’t part of our rating system, so these scores are shown in grey.

?

Determined by how much the mattress edge sinks under applied weight. A mattress with average to good edge support will score 5/10 or higher.

7.5 /10

Edge Support

?

Determined by measuring a medicine ball’s impact on the mattress. Average to good motion isolation would be 5/10 or higher.

7.5 /10

Motion Isolation

?

Determined by dropping a medicine ball onto the mattress. The higher the first bounce, the higher the score out of 10.

5.8 /10

Bounce

?

Determined by entering a mattress’s cooling features into our scoring algorithm. The more effective cooling features that are present, the higher the score out of 10.

4.4 /10

Cooling Features

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Breakdown

We compared Logan & Cove Choice and Stearns & Foster Lakeridge to see which mattress is right for you. Both are breathable, Canadian-made hybrid mattresses with a medium-firm feel—but the similarities end there.   

Stearns & Foster Lakeridge has a pillow-top cover, a moisture-resistant upper layer, a two-part gel layer, and a ventilation system to keep the mattress breathable. While Stearns & Foster has above-average motion isolation, it falls short in edge support.

Logan & Cove’s parent company is rated “A+” on BBB and “Excellent” on Trustpilot, with 4,500+ verified five-star customer reviews. Stearns & Foster is a part of Tempur Sealy International, which is rated “A+” with the Better Business Bureau, but with a customer review score of 1.08/5 at the time of publication. On Trustpilot, Stearns & Foster has a “Poor” rating. Some customers have complained about difficulty getting Stearns & Foster to honour the product warranty, as well as issues with their mattresses sagging, which could be attributed to the mattress’s heavy weight. 

Logan & Cove Choice stands out with its plush, quilted cooling cover and innovative cooling technologies. CryoFusion™ cooling nanofibres, cooling gel foam, latex-like Elastex® foam, and a breathable quilted top layer help keep this mattress cool and breathable throughout the night. With over 900 coils and a three-zone comfort system, this mattress offers comprehensive body support, excellent motion isolation, enhanced airflow, and superior edge support. 

We’ve compiled all the essential information about Logan & Cove and Stearns & Foster to help you make an accurate comparison and choose your next mattress.

Logan & Cove Choice 9.6 EARLY BLACK FRIDAY SALE! Get a FREE Bedding Bundle, 50% off Down Alternative Duvets, and 15% off all bedding and bed frames with any mattress purchase. Sale ends November 20th. See website for details >

Stearns & Foster Lakeridge 3.9

Read Logan & Cove Choice Review	Read Stearns & Foster Lakeridge Review
Price (Queen)
$999	$1,199
Sleep Trial Nights
365	N/A
Warranty Years
15	10
Feel
Medium-firm	Medium-firm
Standout Features
365-night risk-free sleep trial 15-year warranty Cooling plush-quilted cover, advanced cooling gel foams Three-zone coil system and over 900 coils for full-body support Ideal for side, back, and stomach sleepers Free return pickup in major metro areas Free bedding bundle with a mattress protector, pillow(s), bed sheets, and pillow protector(s)	N/A-night sleep trial 10-year warranty Gel layer, moisture-resistant upper layer, ventilation system Suitable for side, stomach and back sleepers
Made In
Canada	Canada

Get Canada’s best hybrid mattress and receive a free bedding bundle.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Sizes & Prices

^{* Based on standard sizing. Individual mattress dimensions may vary.}

Get more features for a lower price with Logan & Cove.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Performance Results

Feel

Both Stearns & Foster Lakeridge and Logan & Cove Choice are medium-firm mattresses, but Stearns & Foster has a softer feel and more sinkage. The amount of sinkage could make it more difficult to move and change positions throughout the night. Logan & Cove Choice has less “hug” and more responsiveness than Stearns & Foster Lakeridge, thanks to the latex-like Elastex® layer.

Edge Support

Hybrid mattresses are known for good edge support, thanks to their supportive coil layers. 

However, the Stearns & Foster mattress scored below average for edge support, at just 4.3/10. You may have trouble sitting on the edge of the bed and getting up in the morning, especially if you have mobility issues. 

In comparison, Logan & Cove has very good edge support with a score of 7.5/10. With Logan & Cove, you can comfortably sit on the edge of the bed, making it easy to get in and out of bed.

Motion Isolation

Motion isolation is crucial for an uninterrupted night’s sleep, especially with a restless partner, kids, or pets. Both Stearns & Foster Lakeridge and Logan & Cove Choice excelled in this area, scoring above average.

Stearns & Foster scored 6.3/10, which is above-average for a foam mattress. That said, Logan & Cove earned a higher score of 7.5/10, meaning you should feel minimal disturbance from the other side of the bed.  

Bounce

Hybrid and innerspring mattresses typically offer additional bounce due to their springy coil systems. Stearns & Foster’s bounce score of 3.7/10 is on the lower end for a hybrid mattress. Logan & Cove has a higher rating of 5.8/10, which would be considered slightly above-average for a hybrid mattress. 

Logan & Cove outperforms Stearns & Foster in responsiveness with a higher bounce score, making it easier to change positions at night or get out of bed.

Cooling Features

Logan & Cove Choice and Stearns & Foster Lakeridge both offer cooling features to help sleepers stay comfortable throughout the night. But despite its higher price, Stearns & Foster only earned a cooling features score of 4.7/10. This score is due to the mattress’s moisture-resistant cover, gel foam layer, pocketed coils, and ventilation system.

The more affordable Logan & Cove Choice earned a cooling features score of 4.4/10. This score is due to its cooling nanofibre cover, its top layer of cooling gel and hollow fibre fill, layer of ecoLuxe® cooling gel foam, layer of breathable Elastex® foam, as well as pocketed coils that support airflow and breathability. If you’re looking for a luxury hybrid mattress that keeps temperatures balanced as you sleep, Logan & Cove is your best choice.

Get the hybrid mattress with excellent edge support and motion isolation.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Mattress Construction

Logan & Cove Choice has 4 layers and multiple advanced cooling features such as cooling gel foam and latex-like Elastex® foam. It also contains a layer of aeroduct micro-coils and a three-zone coil system for full-body support and responsive pressure relief. 

Stearns & Foster Lakeridge has 5 layers, including cooling gel foam, support foam, and packed coils. These layers combine to provide good body contouring and motion isolation. However, it’s not clear what one of the foam layers if made of, since it’s not included in the construction diagram on the Costco website.

Logan & Cove Choice Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The first layer is 1″ of breathable hollow fibre fill and cooling gel-infused foam. It’s quilted directly under the tight-top cover, providing a degree of plushness and directly dissipating your body heat when you’re lying down.
• Layer 2: The second layer is 1″ of ecoLuxe® cooling gel foam. This foam layer provides excellent comfort and pressure-point relief, conforming to your body’s shape while also wicking away heat and moisture.
• Layer 3: The third layer is 1″ of Elastex® foam. This layer contours around your body, providing latex-like responsiveness and pressure relief, but without any of the allergy-causing chemicals in many natural latex mattresses.
• Layer 4: The support layer is 9″ of individually pocketed coils. Made of double-tempered steel, these coils are divided into 3 body-supporting zones to give contouring support for your back and hips. This layer is also encased with 4″-thick edge support foam along the sidewalls to give you more support when sitting on your bed, or lying farther away from the middle.

Logan & Cove distinguishes itself with a plush, quilted cover made using polyester, high-density polyethylene (HDPE), and spandex, and CryoFusion™ cooling nanofibres. Combined with the top layer’s breathable hollow fibre fill and gel-infused foam, the cover’s cooling nanofibres create a cool-to-the-touch and luxuriously soft surface. The mattress cover isn’t removable and should only be spot-cleaned.

Stearns & Foster Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The gel foam comfort layer contours to your body’s shape, relieves pressure, and helps keep you cool during the night.
• Layer 2: The memory foam layer adds extra comfort. Because it’s below the cooling top layer, you may not notice the overheating that’s often associated with memory foam.
• Layer 3: This is the thickest foam layer, but it’s not clear what type of foam it’s made of. This layer doesn’t appear in the construction diagram shown on the Costco website.
• Layer 4: This layer is made up of packed coils that support your body while you sleep. It’s not clear how many coils there are or what type of metal they’re composed of.
• Layer 5: The foam support layer helps provide structure for all the layers above. A mattress’s support layer often has a higher foam density than other layers, but we weren’t able to determine material or density for Lakeridge.

Stearns & Foster’s mattress cover also isn’t machine washable. It incorporates TENCEL fibres, which is a breathable moisture-wicking fabric often found in athletic wear. However, the pillow-top provides a “sink” that may trap heat, negating the mattress cover‘s cooling benefits.

Get the best cooling luxury hybrid mattress in Canada.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Delivery, Sleep Trial & Returns

Costco provides free shipping and a “white-glove” delivery service, which includes transporting the mattress to your desired location, setting it up, and removing all packaging materials. This free shipping service is useful for those who can’t transport a mattress in their vehicle, especially since Stearns & Foster Lakeridge is quite heavy (127 lb for a queen size; 165 lb for a king). Delivery time (including shipping dispatch) can take 10–15 business days, which may not be ideal if you want to receive your mattress immediately. 

Logan & Cove delivers via FedEx, conveniently bringing your mattress right to your doorstep in 2–11 business days. Shipping is free across most of Canada, but there may be extra delivery costs for remote areas. Each mattress is packaged in a sturdy cardboard box and wrapped in heavy-duty plastic. After unboxing and unrolling, the Logan & Cove mattress expands completely within minutes, allowing you to use it the same day it arrives.

Logan & Cove has a risk-free 365-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty. You can return your mattress for a full refund, and Logan & Cove will pick up returns for free within the sleep trial period. They will either donate your returned mattress to a local charity in your area or recycle the mattress if a donation isn’t possible.

With Stearns & Foster, you’ll have a 10-year warranty offered through the manufacturer. While Stearns & Foster has a N/A-night sleep trial, you can also use Costco’s normal extended return policy. If you’re unsatisfied with your mattress and you want to return it, Costco will pick up online orders. If you purchased it in-store, you’ll need to bring it back to the store yourself.

Choose the best hybrid mattress with a longer warranty.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice

Should You Buy Logan & Cove or Stearns & Foster?

Buy the winning mattress now.

Shop Logan & Cove Choice