Douglas vs Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison (2024)

Grace Struth

Sleep Content Lead

• Up-to-Date

  i

  The information included in each mattress review at the time of publication is accurate to the best of our knowledge.
  
  Our reviews do not speak for future versions of these mattresses.

• Methodology

  i

  We test and review the industry’s most popular mattresses using a weighted scoring system factoring in 40+ criteria.
  Learn more >

Which Is Better: Tempur-Pedic or Douglas?

Tempur-Pedic has a reputation for quality mattresses, but even their entry-level products come with a large price tag. Douglas, on the other hand, has an equally excellent reputation for quality at a much more affordable price. It also comes with superior motion isolation, a 365-night sleep trial, and a 20-year warranty.

Top Pick 2024

Winner:

Douglas

Douglas Original outscored Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud in head-to-head mattress testing conducted by third-party engineers (commissioned by us).

EARLY BLACK FRIDAY SALE!
Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% off Bamboo Sheets, and 15% off all bed frames and bedding.
Sale ends November 22nd. See website for details >

Read Review Shop Now

What We Love

• 365-night sleep trial to make sure you love your mattress.
• Premium foam with cooling gel for a more comfortable night’s sleep.
• Unmatched value at just $799 for a queen size.

Overall Ratings

Edge support and motion isolation are factored into our overall mattress ratings. These scores are shown in green (scores of 5.0+), yellow (3.0–4.9), or red (2.9 and below). Firmness, bounce, and cooling features are a matter of personal preference and aren’t part of our rating system, so these scores are shown in grey.

?

Determined by how much the mattress sinks under applied weight. The lower the score out of 10, the softer the mattress.

6.7 /10

Firmness

?

Determined by how much the mattress edge sinks under applied weight. A mattress with average to good edge support will score 5/10 or higher.

7.8 /10

Edge Support

?

Determined by measuring a medicine ball’s impact on the mattress. Average to good motion isolation would be 5/10 or higher.

8.3 /10

Motion Isolation

?

Determined by dropping a medicine ball onto the mattress. The higher the first bounce, the higher the score out of 10.

3.1 /10

Bounce

?

Determined by entering a mattress’s cooling features into our scoring algorithm. The more effective cooling features that are present, the higher the score out of 10.

4.2 /10

Cooling Features

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Breakdown

When comparing Douglas vs Tempur-Pedic, Douglas showed significantly better motion isolation in third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us). Douglas Original also comes at a much lower price point than Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud and comes with a 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty. Douglas even has a machine-washable cover for added convenience—and unlike Tempur-Pedic, Douglas doesn’t contain fiberglass.

We’ve gathered all the information you need to accurately compare these mattresses and choose the one that’s right for you.

Douglas Original 9.9 EARLY BLACK FRIDAY SALE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% off Bamboo Sheets, and 15% off all bed frames and bedding. Sale ends November 22nd. See website for details >

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud 3.6

Read Douglas Original Review	Read Tempur-Pedic Review
Price (Queen)
$799	$2,799
Sleep Trial Nights
365	90
Warranty Years
20	10
Feel
Medium-firm	Medium-firm
Standout Features
365-night risk-free sleep trial 20-year warranty Superior motion isolation Cooling gel comfort layer Free shipping, returns & pickups in major metro areas Free bedding bundle with mattress protector, pillow(s), sheets, and pillow protector(s) Convenient online purchasing and boxed delivery Available in RV sizes 16,300+ verified five-star reviews	90-night sleep trial 10-year warranty CertiPur-US® certified foams North American-based brand Free shipping across Canada
Made In
Canada	United States

Choose the affordable mattress with the 365-night sleep trial.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Sizes & Prices

^{* Based on standard sizing. Individual mattress dimensions may vary.}

Spend less money on more features when you choose Douglas.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Performance Results

Firmness

In third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us), Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud scored 5.5/10 for firmness. While TEMPUR-Cloud is marketed as having a medium feel, this rating places TEMPUR-Cloud at the lowest end of the medium-firm category. Despite being more firm, it has a good amount of “hug” in the top layer, which may make it difficult to change positions.

The Douglas Original is designed to be medium-firm, with a firmness score of 6.7/10. This balance makes it suitable for all sleep styles and preferred by many Canadians. The Douglas provides gentle contouring around your body with minimal sinking, offering a slightly firmer feel and less “hug.”

Edge Support

Foam mattresses often have low edge support. However, both Douglas and Tempur-Pedic scored well for edge support in third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us). Douglas scored 7.8/10, and Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud scored 8.5/10. You can safely sit at the side or foot of either mattress without tumbling off. It should also be easy to get out of bed in the morning.

Motion Isolation

Foam mattresses usually offer better motion isolation than innerspring and hybrid mattresses. This means you should notice less movement from other areas of the mattress while you’re sleeping. Douglas scored very well for motion isolation with a 8.3/10, so you can expect a restful, undisturbed sleep.

Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, scored 4.6/10 for motion isolation. This is considerably lower than Douglas’s score—and lower than we would expect to see in a foam mattress, period. If you or your partner are a restless sleeper, Douglas is a better option for a good night’s rest.

Bounce

Both Douglas and Tempur-Pedic have a low level of bounce, which is common for foam mattresses. Douglas scored 3.1/10 while Tempur-Pedic scored 3.6/10. These scores are very similar, so you might not notice a difference in bounce level. However, if you’d like as little bounce as possible, Douglas would be a better fit for your bedroom.

Cooling Features

Foam can be known to trap heat, so most modern foam mattresses incorporate cooling features to help ensure breathability and airflow for comfortable sleep. Douglas achieves this by incorporating features such as a CoolSense® cover, ecoLight® cooling gel foam layer, and a layer of Elastex, a breathable latex-like foam. All these features earned Douglas a score of 4.2/10.

TEMPUR-Cloud, also a foam mattress, received a cooling features score of just 1.6/10. Despite being promoted as a cooling mattress, the company doesn’t explain exactly what those cooling technologies are. We could only identify two features: the top cover made with moisture-wicking fabric and a layer of pocket coils. These scores indicate you’re more likely to have a cooler and more comfortable sleep on a Douglas Original.

Ready to buy the best foam mattress on the market?

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Construction

Douglas Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The 2″ top layer of the Douglas mattress is made of ecoLight® cooling gel foam. It’s just as durable, comfortable, and body-contouring as memory foam, minus the late-night heat. It’s also more eco-conscious.
• Layer 2: The 2″ middle layer is made of Elastex® foam for extra spring and support. This foam is latex-free, making it a good option if you’re sensitive to latex.
• Layer 3: The 6″ bottom layer is made of motion isolation support foam. This means you’ll hardly feel a thing from the other side of the bed, even if your partner is tossing and turning all night long.

Tempur-Pedic Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The comfort layer is roughly 2″ of TEMPUR® foam. This layer is described as soft and supportive. Unfortunately, the TEMPUR-Cloud website doesn’t share the exact thickness of this layer or its foam density.
• Layer 2: The transition layer is around 2″ of TEMPUR® foam. The TEMPUR-Cloud website describes this as a firmer support layer that slowly adapts and conforms to your body for pressure-point relief. Similar to the comfort layer, the exact measurements and foam density of this layer aren’t available.
• Layer 3: The support layer contains about 6″ of premium foam. This layer helps the mattress stay structured and supportive.

Tempur-Pedic doesn’t publicly share its layer measurements or foam densities. Douglas is more open with this information. The Douglas website states that foam density is 2.5 lb/ft³.

The sustainable Infinitex™ fibres in Douglas’s cover keep your sleep surface cool and dry. You can remove and machine-wash Douglas’s top cover to keep it fresh using the 360° zipper.

Tempur-Pedic, on the other hand, has a polyester-and-spandex cover that isn’t removable or machine washable. This could be partly because TEMPUR-Cloud contains 23% “glass fiber” (fiberglass) in its internal fire sock netting. (We safely removed the cover for the purposes of this comparison but don’t recommend doing the same at home.) Instead of removing the cover, spot-clean the mattress carefully when it gets dirty.

Pick the mattress with a machine-washable top cover.

Shop Douglas Original

Delivery, Sleep Trial & Returns

Tempur-Pedic and Douglas ship by ground using FedEx. Shipping is free across most of Canada, but you may need to pay an additional fee for delivery to remote locations. Including time taken to dispatch and deliver orders, Douglas arrives ar your doorstep in 2–10 business days, and Tempur-Pedic should arrive in 5–7 business days.

Douglas comes in a recyclable cardboard box and is protected by two layers of heavy-duty plastic. Tempur-Pedic is delivered in a bag, which isn’t reusable once you remove the mattress. 

Warranty and returns are very different for Douglas vs Tempur-Pedic. Douglas comes with a 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty, which are among the best in the industry. You can return your mattress at any time after 21 nights and receive a full refund with free mattress pickup.

Tempur-Pedic only offers a 90-night trial and 10-year warranty. You can return the mattress after sleeping on it for 30 nights, but a return shipping fee will be taken from your refund. If you buy TEMPUR-Cloud through an online retailer, return and warranty policies may be different from what Tempur-Pedic offers.

Get the mattress with the 20-year warranty and 365-night sleep trial.

Shop Douglas Original

Should You Buy Douglas or Tempur-Pedic?

Buy the winning mattress now.

Shop Douglas Original