Casper vs Nectar vs Douglas Comparison (2024)

Brook Bell

Sleep Content Strategist

• Up-to-Date

  i

  The information included in each mattress review at the time of publication is accurate to the best of our knowledge.
  
  Our reviews do not speak for future versions of these mattresses.

• Methodology

  i

  We test and review the industry’s most popular mattresses using a weighted scoring system factoring in 40+ criteria.
  Learn more >

Which Is Better: Casper, Nectar, or Douglas?

Douglas, Casper, and Nectar are three well-known mattress-in-a-box brands available in Canada. But only the Canadian-made Douglas offers superior edge support and motion isolation, contains advanced cooling features, and comes with a free bedding bundle. Best of all, Douglas is affordably priced at just $799 for a queen size—offering great value for your dollar.

Top Pick 2024

Winner:

Douglas

Douglas outscored The Casper and Nectar Original in independent testing conducted by third-party engineers (commissioned by us).

EARLY BLACK FRIDAY SALE!
Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% off Bamboo Sheets, and 15% off all bed frames and bedding.
Sale ends November 22nd. See website for details >

Read Review Shop Now

What We Love

• Superior motion isolation and edge support for undisturbed sleep.
• Premium cooling gel foam to keep you comfortable throughout the night.
• Free bedding bundle with a mattress protector, pillow(s), sheets, and pillow protector(s).

Overall Ratings

Edge support and motion isolation are factored into our overall mattress ratings. These scores are shown in green (scores of 5.0+), yellow (3.0–4.9), or red (2.9 and below). Firmness, bounce, and cooling features are a matter of personal preference and aren’t part of our rating system, so these scores are shown in grey.

?

Determined by how much the mattress edge sinks under applied weight. A mattress with average to good edge support will score 5/10 or higher.

7.8 /10

Edge Support

?

Determined by measuring a medicine ball’s impact on the mattress. Average to good motion isolation would be 5/10 or higher.

8.3 /10

Motion Isolation

?

Determined by dropping a medicine ball onto the mattress. The higher the first bounce, the higher the score out of 10.

3.1 /10

Bounce

?

Determined by entering a mattress’s cooling features into our scoring algorithm. The more effective cooling features that are present, the higher the score out of 10.

4.2 /10

Cooling Features

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Breakdown

When comparing Douglas vs Casper vs Nectar, Douglas Original outperforms both The Casper and Nectar Original in delivering an elite sleep experience. With outstanding scores in edge support and motion isolation, a low bounce for undisturbed sleep, and advanced cooling features, Douglas offers comfort and support for every sleeper. It also comes with a free sheet set, pillow(s), mattress protector, and pillow protector(s) to elevate your mattress purchase.

To help you choose between Douglas, Casper and Nectar, we’ve gathered all the information you need to accurately compare these mattresses.

Douglas Original 9.9 EARLY BLACK FRIDAY SALE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% off Bamboo Sheets, and 15% off all bed frames and bedding. Sale ends November 22nd. See website for details >

The Casper 5.3

Nectar Original 6.9

Read Douglas Original Review	Read The Casper Review	Read Nectar Original Review
Price (Queen)
$799	$1,499	$799
Sleep Trial Nights
365	100	365
Warranty Years
20	10	Lifetime
Feel
Medium-firm	Medium-firm	Medium-firm
Standout Features
365-night sleep trial 20-year warranty Suitable for side, back, and stomach sleepers Superior motion isolation and above-average edge support Multiple cooling features Free bedding bundle with purchase Machine-washable cover Available in split king and multiple RV sizes Company rated “A+” on BBB and “Excellent” on Trustpilot	100-night sleep trial 10-year warranty Suitable for side, back, and stomach sleepers Above-average edge support and motion isolation Some cooling features Available to try in some stores	365-night sleep trial Lifetime warranty Suitable for side, back, and stomach sleepers Average motion isolation Some cooling features Available to try in some stores
Made In
Canada	United States	Mexico

Choose Douglas, the mattress with the 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Sizes & Prices

^{* Based on standard sizing. Individual mattress dimensions may vary.}

Get the best quality foam mattress within your budget when you choose Douglas.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Performance Results

Firmness

When comparing Casper vs Nectar vs Douglas, they all fall within the medium-firm category for firmness. This is an ideal firmness level whether you sleep on your side, stomach, or back. However, there are some differences in the support level of each mattress.

Nectar Original feels like a medium-firm mattress with a significant amount of “hug.” Nectar says its mattress is ideal for all sleepers, but independent reviews on r/mattress don’t always agree. The Casper also has lots of “hug” despite its medium-firm feel, so you may require more support if you sleep on your stomach.

Douglas Original, on the other hand, has less “hug” in the top layer, meaning you’ll get the support you need while still benefitting from the temperature-balancing comfort of its cooling gel foam. You should be able to sleep comfortably on Douglas Original in any position.

Edge Support

Foam mattresses aren’t generally known for having good edge support. However, Douglas sets itself apart with its exceptional edge support, thanks to the all-around sidewalls. With a superior edge support rating of 7.8/10, Douglas lets you comfortably sit or lie on the bed’s edge without any fear of slipping off.

Casper also received an above-average score for edge support at 7.5/10. While this is a good score, it’s still lower than Douglas’s. When comparing Douglas and Casper vs Nectar, however, Nectar falls short with a score of just 1.9/10 for edge support. Nectar likely won’t provide you with the edge support you need in a mattress.

Motion Isolation

If you’re searching for a foam mattress with excellent motion isolation, Douglas comes out on top with a score of 8.3/10. This should help ensure a restful sleep, undisturbed by your partner’s movements. Casper scored much lower at 6.6/10, and Nectar scored the lowest at 5.0/10. Both mattresses offer some motion isolation, but they just don’t measure up to Douglas.

Bounce

Low bounce is important if you’re a light sleeper who’s easily woken. Comparing Nectar vs Casper, Casper scored a 4.7/10 for bounce, which is average for a foam mattress. The Nectar mattress had a lower bounce score of 3.6/10. However, Douglas has the lowest bounce score of all three mattresses at 5.5/10—a nice side benefit of its excellent motion isolation.

Cooling Features

Foam mattresses can be known to trap heat, so most modern foam mattresses incorporate cooling features to help ensure breathability and airflow for comfortable sleep. Douglas, Casper, and Nectar all feature cooling elements in their foam layers—but some mattresses have more features than others.

Nectar Original earned a cooling features score of 2.4/10 because of its cool-to-the-touch cover and gel-infused foam layer. The Casper performed similarly, with its open-cell foam and perforated foam layer earning a score of 2.5/10.

Douglas Original was the top performer for cooling features with a score of 4.2/10. Douglas’s moisture-wicking CoolSense® cover, a layer of ecoLight® cooling gel foam, and a layer of breathable Elastex® foam all contributed to this score. If you’re looking for a refreshing mattress to keep temperatures balanced as you sleep, Douglas is your best choice.

Get exceptional edge support, motion isolation, and cooling with Douglas.

Shop Douglas Original

Mattress Construction

Douglas Original, The Casper, and Nectar Original are all combination foam mattresses with three layers each. At different heights and with different materials, these mattresses feature layers for comfort, transition, and support.

Douglas Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The 2″ top layer of the Douglas mattress is made of ecoLight® cooling gel foam. It’s just as durable, comfortable, and body-contouring as memory foam, minus the late-night heat. It’s also more eco-conscious.
• Layer 2: The 2″ middle layer is made of Elastex® foam for extra spring and support. This foam is latex-free, making it a good option if you’re sensitive to latex.
• Layer 3: The 6″ bottom layer is made of motion isolation support foam. This means you’ll hardly feel a thing from the other side of the bed, even if your partner is tossing and turning all night long.

Douglas Original’s top cover is removable and machine washable for easy care. It’s also made using plant-based Infinitex™ fibres that wick moisture and help keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night.

Casper Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The top (comfort) layer includes 1″ of polyurethane foam, which uses open-cell perforations to enhance airflow. Casper says this feature promotes comfort and regulates body temperature during sleep.
• Layer 2: The middle (transition) layer is 2″ of body-contouring memory foam. This supports your body and prevents long-term sagging in the middle of the mattress. However, memory foam is known for heat trapping, and there aren’t any advanced cooling features to cancel out that effect.
• Layer 3: The bottom (support) layer is 7″ of dense polyurethane support foam. This foundational component maintains the mattress’s structure and support, ensuring that you won’t sink too far into the upper layers.

The Casper’s polyester, cotton, rayon, and lycra top cover isn’t removable despite having a zipper. This means the cover isn’t machine washable, so you should spot-clean it in the case of spills or stains.

Nectar Mattress Layers

• Layer 1: The 2″ comfort layer is made of plush gel memory foam that’s designed to provide pressure-relieving, body-contouring support. Foam density is unknown.
• Layer 2: The transition layer is 3″ of conventional foam that Nectar claims provides support, spinal alignment, and bounce. However, our independent testing showed that Nectar received a below-average bounce score of 3.6/10. The lower the bounce rating, the more difficult it may be to change sleeping positions. Foam density is reportedly 3.5 lb/ft³.
• Layer 3: The 7″ base layer is made of conventional foam, and Nectar says it has a density of 2.2 lb/ft³.

The Nectar’s top cover is made of polyester, nylon, and polyethylene to create a cool-to-the-touch feel. While the Nectar mattress cover shows an icon of a washing machine and features the words “machine-washable”, Nectar’s warranty says that removing the cover will void your warranty. To be safe, you should spot-clean this mattress.

Pick Douglas, the mattress with a cooling, machine-washable cover.

Shop Douglas Original

Delivery, Sleep Trial & Returns

Douglas ships its mattresses for free to most locations in Canada using FedEx. Nectar ships using various couriers but doesn’t deliver to Nunavut. Casper delivers its mattresses through UPS. For all three mattress brands, additional fees may apply for some remote locations and may result in longer shipping times.

Since Douglas mattresses are handmade in Canada, any mattresses ordered will ship from their warehouses in Ontario and Alberta. Casper mattresses are made in the United States, but it’s not clear where they ship from. If you’d prefer to buy your mattress in person, there are some brick-and-mortar stores where Casper mattresses are available.

According to the Nectar website, the company manufactures its mattresses in Vietnam, Malaysia, China, Mexico, and the United States. They’re dispatched from the brand’s American distribution centre. (Nectar’s parent company, Resident Home LLC, has previously faced charges from the FTC for making false “Made in the USA” claims. They were asked to pay $753,000 to settle the charges.)

While Casper mattresses take anywhere from 5–15 business days to arrive, your Douglas mattress will arrive at your door in 2–10 business days. Nectar mattresses will be delivered in 3–7 business days.

All three mattresses come compressed and rolled in heavy-duty plastic and packaged in a convenient cardboard box. Once unpacked, the Douglas and Casper mattresses expand in minutes, while Nectar Original takes up to 72 hours to fully expand.

When comparing Douglas vs Casper vs Nectar, they all offer different sleep trial and warranty lengths. Douglas offers a generous 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty. Casper offers a 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty. If you purchase your Casper mattress through Sleep Country, you’ll only be eligible for exchanges, not a full refund. Nectar Original will come with a 365-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty, although some customers have reported issues getting Nectar to honour this warranty.

In addition to customer complaints, Nectar is rated “Poor” on Trustpilot, and has only a 3/5 star rating with the Better Business Bureau at the time of this review. Casper is rated “A+” on BBB but has a 1/5 star rating, and is rated “Average” on Trustpilot. In comparison, Douglas’s parent company maintains a rating of “Excellent” on Trustpilot and “A+” on BBB with a 4.89/5 star rating.

Choose the company rated “A+” on BBB and “Excellent” on Trustpilot.

Shop Douglas Original

Should You Buy Douglas, Casper, or Nectar?

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Douglas Original